awesome-copilot/plugins/doublecheck/skills/doublecheck/assets/verification-report-template.md

Verification Report

Summary

Text verified: [Brief description of what was checked] Claims extracted: [N total] Breakdown:

Rating	Count
VERIFIED
PLAUSIBLE
UNVERIFIED
DISPUTED
FABRICATION RISK

Items requiring attention: [N items rated DISPUTED or FABRICATION RISK]

---

Flagged Items (Review These First)

Items rated DISPUTED or FABRICATION RISK. These need your attention before you rely on the source material.

[C#] -- [Brief description of the claim]

• Claim: [The specific assertion from the target text]
• Rating: [DISPUTED or FABRICATION RISK]
• Finding: [What the verification found -- what's wrong or suspicious]
• Source: [URL to contradicting or relevant source]
• Recommendation: [What the user should do -- e.g., "Verify this citation in Westlaw" or "Remove this statistic unless you can find a primary source"]

---

All Claims

Full results for every extracted claim, grouped by confidence rating.

VERIFIED

[C#] -- [Brief description]

• Claim: [The assertion]
• Source: [URL]
• Notes: [Any relevant context about the source]

PLAUSIBLE

[C#] -- [Brief description]

• Claim: [The assertion]
• Notes: [Why this is rated plausible rather than verified]

UNVERIFIED

[C#] -- [Brief description]

• Claim: [The assertion]
• Notes: [What was searched, why nothing was found]

DISPUTED

[C#] -- [Brief description]

• Claim: [The assertion]
• Contradicting source: [URL]
• Details: [What the source says vs. what the claim says]

FABRICATION RISK

[C#] -- [Brief description]

• Claim: [The assertion]
• Pattern: [Which hallucination pattern this matches]
• Details: [Why this is flagged -- e.g., "citation not found in any legal database"]

---

Internal Consistency

[Any contradictions found within the target text itself, or "No internal contradictions detected."]

---

What Was Not Checked

[List any claims that could not be evaluated -- paywalled sources, claims requiring specialized databases, unfalsifiable assertions, etc.]

---

Limitations

• This tool accelerates human verification; it does not replace it.
• Web search results may not include the most recent information or paywalled sources.
• The adversarial review uses the same underlying model that may have produced the original output. It catches many issues but cannot catch all of them.
• A claim rated VERIFIED means a supporting source was found, not that the claim is definitely correct. Sources can be wrong too.
• Claims rated PLAUSIBLE may still be wrong. The absence of contradicting evidence is not proof of accuracy.